Colorectal cancer: New guidelines add 2 types of screening tools

Evan Walker
Evan Walker TheMediTary.Com |
A lab technician preparing a blood sample.Share on Pinterest
New colorectal cancer guidelines from the ACS highlight noninvasive screening methods. Image credit: Marco Govel/Stocksy
  • The American Cancer Society (ACS) updated its colorectal cancer screening guidelines to include new blood-based and at-home stool tests, while continuing to recommend screening for average-risk adults beginning at age 45.
  • New screening options include the at-home stool tests Cologuard and ColoSense, both recommended every 3 years, as well as the blood-based test Shield for people who decline other preferred screening methods.
  • The ACS states that colonoscopy remains the gold standard for colorectal cancer screening, and a colonoscopy should follow any positive result from a stool or blood-based test within 6 months.
  • The guideline changes aim to improve screening participation and reduce colorectal cancer deaths, as colorectal cancer rates continue to rise among adults younger than age 50.

Colorectal cancer is the third most common cancer worldwide, and the second leading cause of cancer-related deaths worldwide.

Early-onset colorectal cancer, which occurs in adults under 50, is rising globally at an alarming rate in younger adults, with research highlighting that it is the leading cause of cancer-related death among males and females under age 50.

Previous colorectal cancer screening guidelines from the ACS advised that average-risk adults aged 45 years and older undergo regular screening with either a stool-based test or a visual exam, based on personal preferences and test availability. It also recommends a timely colonoscopy after all positive results on non-colonoscopy screening tests.

Now, the ACS has updated its screening guidelines to expand the range of recommended screening tools, including new blood-based and at-home stool tests designed to improve participation and detect cancer earlier.

Published in CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, the updated recommendations continue to advise that adults at average risk begin screening for colorectal cancer at age 45 and continue through age 75 and up to 85, depending on their preference and overall health. They also advise that individuals at higher risk may need to begin screening before age 45 and undergo testing more frequently.

The revised guidance reflects growing concern over rising colorectal cancer rates among younger adults, as well as persistent screening gaps across the United States.

Older evidence indicates that more than 20 million eligible Americans remain unscreened for colorectal cancer, which is approximately one-third of adults who should be tested.

Experts involved in the update suggest that expanding the number of available screening methods may help remove barriers for people who are reluctant or unable to undergo traditional colonoscopy procedures.

Screening can significantly improve survival outcomes, particularly when the disease is detected early. Evidence suggests that the 5-year survival rate can exceed 90% when colorectal cancer is diagnosed at an early stage.

By updating their guidance, the ACS hopes more eligible adults will participate in colorectal cancer screening, helping close the screening gap and catch more cancers at an earlier, treatable stage.

Robert Smith, PhD, Senior Vice President, Cancer Screening at the American Cancer Society, and senior author of the updated guidelines, told Medical News Today that the updated guidelines are an opportunity to reinforce the foundation of the recommendations and highlight what is new.

When should I start screening?

“Adults at average risk of colorectal cancer should begin regular screening at age 45. If they are past the age of 45 and have not started screening, it is important to do so now. Options for colorectal cancer screening include visual tests, of which the most commonly chosen is colonoscopy every 10 years, and stool tests, of which there are options for annual testing or testing every 3 years.”
— Robert Smith, PhD

“With this update, we review an update of an existing multi-target stool-DNA test, which tests for blood in the stool or abnormal DNA, and a new multi-target stool-RNA test, which tests for blood in the stool and abnormal RNA fragments,” Smith said.

“These two tests are recommended to be done every 3 years. We also add to the recommendations a blood-test option, which should only be recommended to individuals who decline or have not completed a high-sensitivity stool-based test or visual exam,” he added.

The ACS suggests that blood-based tests should primarily be for those who decline or do not complete preferred screening methods, such as stool testing or colonoscopy.

Colonoscopy remains the preferred visual exam

The guideline also highlights that a positive result from any blood or stool-based screening test must be followed by a colonoscopy, ideally within 6 months, to complete the screening process.

“If a non-colonoscopy colorectal cancer screening test is positive, it must be followed up with a colonoscopy, or the screening process is not complete,” Smith emphasized to MNT. “It is critically important, but many patients with positive findings on a stool test do not get followed up with a colonoscopy.”

“There are numerous reasons, including not appreciating the importance of the follow-up colonoscopy, difficulty getting an appointment, concerns about costs (it should be covered at no cost to individuals with insurance), the complexity of preparing for colonoscopy, the need to get time off from work, the need to arrange for a chaperone to drive the patient home from the exam, etc. Strong encouragement from the healthcare team is essential,” he explained.

Although new technologies are being added, the updated recommendations continue to support traditional visual screening methods, including colonoscopy every 10 years, flexible sigmoidoscopy every 5 years, and CT colonography every 5 years.

At-home stool tests such as fecal immunochemical tests (FIT) and guaiac-based fecal occult blood tests (gFOBT) also remain part of the recommendations.

Which test is best to screen for colorectal cancer?

The ACS reiterates that the best screening test is ultimately the one a person is willing and able to complete.

“Patient preference is very important, and in fact, our guideline recommends that clinicians should not direct patients to a specific test but initially recommend that individuals consider either a visual examination or a stool test,” Smith adds.

“Too often clinicians simply advise patients to get a colonoscopy, and the evidence shows that many individuals do not wish to undergo an invasive test,” he said.

2 types of stool testing

“If they would prefer another option, then there are two types of stool testing options: high-sensitivity stool-blood tests or the multi-target stool DNA or RNA tests, which test for both blood and abnormal molecular markers in stool. The multi-target stool DNA tests (the multi-target RNA test is new) have steadily gained uptake over the years and are now the most commonly used stool test among individuals who choose a stool testing option.”
— Robert Smith, PhD

Share this Article